Review: Under the Same Stars by Libba Bray

Under the Same Stars by Libba Bray
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

I was provided an ALC of this book via Netgalley, all opinions are my own.

The narrators January LaVoy, Jeremy Carlisle Parker, and Major Curda were excellent! LaVoy is one of my all time favorites and I will listen to anything she narrates, but the addition of the 2 other narrators to voice Miles and the Grandmother on the tape telling the story were perfect choices. They really brought the 3 interconnected stories to life.

This follows 3 interconnected stories, and I'll admit it took me a while to figure out how they were all connected but I eventually put it all together. This follows best friends Sophie and Hanna in the 1940's in Germany as the Nazis are establishing their hold. As teenagers they are maturing from girls into women and putting their beloved fairytales and folklore behind them like the famous Bridegroom's Oak that is said to make love matches and send messages between lovers. The oak tree becomes a key part in the events that take place in their town not only when it comes to romance but to save lives. In the 19080 we meet Jenny, who has moved to Germany from Texas because of her father's job. Her parents want her to be one way but she is desperate to find her true identity. Lena a punk rocker just might hold the key to unlocking that identity as she shows her the real Germany and introduces Jenny to the punk scene. Then we have Miles, who is stuck alone doing virtual school and terrified to go outside during the COVID pandemic. His moms can't come home due to travel and Covid protocols, so he has to fend for himself. His best friend Chloe gets a strange package from her ailing grandmother that leads them to investigate two missing teenagers from 80 years ago around the Bridegroom's Oak. Those teens are Sophie and Hannah, which unfolds a story that connects Miles, Chloe, the missing girls, and Jenny in a very unexpected way.

I really liked the way this was told. It has the same beautiful writing you would expect if you have every read Libba Bray in the past. The interwoven storylines was a creative way to tell this tale. Despite the fact that all three storylines are broken up I felt like we got to know all of the characters pretty well. We see growth in all of the characters as they face their fears and opposition, stand up to bullies, and stand up for what they believe in. I also thought that the recording of the fairy tale by Chloe's grandmother was a nice touch, it not only helped with the investigation, but as with all fairy tales it was a way to hide what was really going on at the time and tell the real story of what happened.

I'm a huge fan of The Diviner's series, I grew up in the 80s, survived COVID, and I love WWII historical fiction. This book was a huge win for me. I love Libba Bray's writing, though this does not have the fantasy elements that Diviner's had. This touches on alot of things in the various historical events of the 1940s and 1980s in Germany as well as the spring of 2020 pandemic that we all just lived through. If those time periods and events are going to be triggering for you, take care and maybe shelve this one for later. I thought the author did a great job discussing the political landscapes of each time period and some of the horrible events that occurred.

View all my reviews